Convention Paper
Comparison between Spherical Headmodels and HRTFs in Upmixing for Headphone-Based Virtual Surround and Stereo Expansion—Part I
AES Convention 129 · Paper 8269 · November 2010
Abstract
In this paper, a first of multiple-parts, we compare the
performance of headmodels with head-related transfer functions
(HRTFs), which have previously been published, using different
upmixing techniques for headphone virtual surround. We consider a
spherical head, with and without the pinna or the torso model,
whereas for the HRTFs we incorporate the CIPIC, Nagoya, and MIT
HRTF sets in the up-mixing. The up-mixing technique includes using
the Moorer reverberator, a modified Moorer reverberator and
modeling the direct sound, the first several discrete reflections
(with adjustable delay and amplitude) and the diffuse field
reflections with a tunable frequency dependent decorrelator.
Furthermore, since the measured HRTFs can introduce audible
coloration we investigate if there is a trade-off between
localization and timbre by incorporating complex-domain smoothing
of the HRTF time responses. To evaluate the localization and
timbre performance between the models we use movie and music
content (viz., stereo, ITU downmix, and a commercial down-mix
method) as well as Gaussian tone noise bursts of critical
bandwidth.
